Types of theses: literature review, empirical study, and mixed methods compared

All videos of the tutorial Writing a bachelor's/master's thesis and optimizing it with AI
Markus Quanz
By Markus Quanz Last updated on

The choice of method determines how your thesis is structured, how much time you need, and what skills you need to bring to it. Many students settle on a topic too early without knowing what lies ahead. If you know the different types of work, you can choose more deliberately. In this guide, you will learn about three basic types and one hybrid form: the literature or review paper, the empirical study, Design Science Research, and the mixed-methods approach.

8 - Types of Theses

The video is only loaded from YouTube when you play it – data (including your IP address) is then transmitted to YouTube/Google. More in the privacy policy

Key Takeaways

  • A literature paper consists of theory and an evaluation of the current state of research. For this you need reading skills, perseverance, and good English.
  • An empirical study is based on your own experiments or test bench trials. Definitely plan time buffers, because delays often occur.
  • Design Science Research develops a practical result, for example software, and improves it in several feedback loops with users.
  • A mixed-methods approach combines the advantages of different approaches and offsets their disadvantages.

Step-by-Step Guide

Step 1: Understanding the Literature or Review Paper

In this type of work, you create an overview of the current state of research. You collect many scientific documents and summarize them in compact form. You answer your research question not through your own data, but through the results that already exist in the literature. A prerequisite is that enough specialist literature exists in your field. In some areas there is already a great deal of material, which you then have to condense to the essentials.

Types of theses: literature review, empirical study, and mixed methods compared

Step 2: Compare Sources Instead of Just Listing Them

A good literature paper does not simply string sources together. You have to delve deep into the subject matter and compare the sources with one another. Ask yourself which concepts and results exist, where different researchers agree and where they contradict each other. Also pay attention to which concepts are no longer current or have been refuted. This very evaluation forms the core of your work and distinguishes a strong paper from a mere list of references.

Types of theses: a comparison of literature-based work, empirical work, and mixed methods

Step 3: Realistically Estimate Scope and Effort

As a rough guideline, at least 50 sources apply. Whether this holds true for your topic, however, depends on the research field. If there are fewer suitable publications, you work with what is available. Plan plenty of time for this type of work, because reading and structuring specialist articles takes concentration. The advantage is that you are flexible with your time, set your own pace, and can do a large part of the work from home. The disadvantage is that the work can quickly seem monotonous and demands a lot of stamina.

Types of theses: comparing literature-based work, empirical work, and mixed methods

Step 4: Consider the Language and the Prospect of a Doctorate

Most scientific papers are written in English. If German is your native language, you will therefore be working permanently in a foreign language with this type of work. This does not have to be a disadvantage, but you should prepare for it and bring solid reading comprehension. If you want to pursue a doctorate after your studies, the effort is especially worthwhile. A detailed state of research can later be incorporated into your dissertation, so that you have already completed a part of it before the actual doctorate begins.

Step 5: Understanding Empirical Work with Your Own Data

In an empirical or experimental thesis, you answer a research question through experiments or test bench trials. Usually you work directly within your supervisor's research project. The supervisor provides you with a research question from the ongoing project, and you then generate your own data. This often makes this type of work more exciting and motivating than a pure literature evaluation, because you work hands-on and obtain results at test benches.

Types of theses: comparing literature-based work, empirical work, and mixed methods

Step 6: Plan for Simulations and Factor in Delays

Before you carry out an experiment, you usually simulate it on the computer. This way you check in advance what should happen. These simulations are an integral part of the preparation. At the same time, you should assume that not everything will work on the first attempt. Components may be delivered late, a workshop may be unavailable, or your supervisor is on vacation and the test bench stays locked. In experimental work, you are much more dependent on other people. Therefore, deliberately plan additional time so that you do not run into time pressure at the end.

Types of theses: comparing literature-based work, empirical work, and mixed methods

Step 7: Use Design Science Research as an iterative development process

Design Science Research comes mainly from computer science. Here you develop a practical result, such as software, and document the process scientifically. The development is not finished once you have completed the first version. Instead, you go through several cycles: you develop the software, give it to potential users to test, and revise it based on their feedback. The next version then follows, until the result is largely convincing. It is rarely perfect, but through repeated improvement you achieve a very good result.

Types of theses: comparing literature-based work, empirical work, and mixed methods

Step 8: Deliberately put together a mixed-methods approach

A mixed-methods approach is not a standalone type of work, but a combination of different methods within one thesis. You use the advantages of different approaches and offset their disadvantages. This often gives you a better thesis than if you had committed to a single method from the start. This variant is also suitable if you do not yet want to commit to one approach.

Types of theses: a comparison of literature-based work, empirical work, and mixed methods

Step 9: Choose the right combination for your topic

A typical example of a mixed-methods approach is a detailed state of the art. You devote most of your thesis to the question of what the current state of research looks like. In addition, at the end you conduct a small experiment to verify individual findings. When making your choice, consider which skills you bring, how much time you have, and whether you have access to laboratory infrastructure or users for feedback. The more honestly you answer these questions, the better the method will fit your topic.

Types of theses: a comparison of literature-based work, empirical work, and mixed methods

Summary – Types of theses at a glance

Various paths are open to you for your thesis, and they differ significantly in effort, working method, and required skills. Literature reviews require above all reading and comparison skills as well as perseverance. Empirical theses thrive on your own data, experiments, and generous time planning. Design Science Research relies on the iterative development of a practical result with user feedback. The mixed-methods approach combines these strengths if you do not want to commit to a single method. It is best to decide based on your topic, your skills, and your time planning.

FAQ

How many sources do I need for a literature review?As a guideline, at least 50 sources apply. However, the research topic is decisive. If there are fewer suitable sources, you work with what exists.

Do I have to write a literature review in German?Most important specialist articles are written in English. You should therefore have good English reading comprehension in order to evaluate the literature reliably.

Why should I run a simulation before an experiment?With a simulation, you check on the computer what should happen. This way you identify problems early, before you invest time at the test bench.

How do I plan the time required for an empirical thesis?Definitely expect delays, for example due to supply shortages, workshop outages, or the supervisor's absence. Therefore deliberately allow more time than you theoretically need.

What does an iterative approach mean in Design Science Research?You develop a result, have users test it, and revise it based on the feedback. You repeat this cycle until the result is convincing.

Is a mixed-methods approach a type of work in its own right?No, a mixed-methods approach is a combination of different methods within one thesis. It is suitable if you want to use the advantages of several approaches.

Can a literature review help with a doctorate?Yes, a detailed state of research can later flow into the dissertation. This means you have already prepared a part of the doctorate.

Markus Quanz
Trainer About Markus Quanz