Clipping with Photoshop: Hair, objects & people

Cutting out objects in Photoshop: combining tools strategically

All videos of the tutorial Clipping with Photoshop: Hair, objects & people
Stefan Petri
By Stefan Petri Last updated on

Many people regard cutting out as a tedious chore in which you spend hours glued to the mouse pointer and still end up with messy edges. Yet the problem usually lies not in the technique, but in the choice of tool. If you know which selection tools suit which subjects and how they complement each other, you will reach a clean result much faster.

Fun with cropping - an excursion into various cropping methods

The video is only loaded from YouTube when you play it – data (including your IP address) is then transmitted to YouTube/Google. More in the privacy policy

In this tutorial, you join me for typical cutout tasks: the Berlin TV Tower against a cloudy sky, a soccer ball in the air, a flower scene, a person in front of a hedge, and a cap being placed on the head in a family photo. You will learn which tools in Photoshop to use and when, how to correct selections, and how to work flexibly with layer masks, smart objects, and adjustment layers. The examples come from a workshop video, but the approach can be applied to your own images.

Key Takeaways

  • No selection tool solves every task. The Lasso, Polygonal Lasso, and Magnetic Lasso are only suitable for rough or very high-contrast subjects, and the Rectangular and Elliptical Marquee for geometric shapes.
  • The Quick Selection tool is the fastest way to get started for many subjects, especially when there is clear contrast with the background.
  • The Magic Wand works well on single-color areas. With the "Contiguous" and "Tolerance" options, you control which pixels are also selected.
  • Holding the Shift key adds areas, and holding the Alt key removes them. This combination is the most important time-saver.
  • The "Refine Edge" function and layer masks ensure clean transitions and can be readjusted at any time.
  • Smart objects and adjustment layers make your work non-destructive and allow later changes without loss of quality.

Step-by-Step Guide

Step 1: Recognizing the Limits of the Simple Lasso Tools

Before you get started, you should know where the classic tools fail. The Lasso tool is hard to guide precisely with a mouse, and with curves the selection quickly becomes angular. The Polygonal Lasso sets selection points by clicking, looks fine on straight edges, but behaves like a rubber band on curves. The Magnetic Lasso follows contrasts, but often loses track as soon as the edge is blurry or similar in color. For the TV Tower against the sky, none of these tools is sufficient. You should therefore use them at most for rough preliminary work or for minor corrections.

Cutting out images in Photoshop: Combining tools strategically

Step 2: Getting a First Boost with the Quick Selection Tool

For many subjects, the Quick Selection tool is the better starting point. You simply drag over the subject with the mouse button held down, and Photoshop detects contrasts and edges on its own. With the TV Tower, a single stroke over the tower is enough, and a large part is already marked. The selection may also overshoot the target, for example into the sky. That is not critical, because you can correct it in the next step. Make sure to choose a view in which you can see the subject well.

Cutting out images in Photoshop: Combining tools strategically

Step 3: Fine-Tuning the Selection with the Shift and Alt Keys

The real strength of the selection tools lies in how they can be combined, as long as the selection is active. Hold the Shift key when you want to add an area, and the Alt key when you want to subtract something. This is much faster than switching between modes in the options bar. This way you can work roughly with the Quick Selection tool and use the Polygonal Lasso or the regular Lasso to close gaps or remove excess in a targeted way. With the TV Tower, for example, you add missing parts of the tower and use Alt to remove the clouds that were accidentally captured.

Cutting out objects in Photoshop: combining tools strategically

Step 4: Working Precisely with Zoom and the Space Bar

Without zoom, clean cutting out is hardly possible. Zoom into the details when working on fine edges, and use the space bar to move the image section without switching tools. With the space bar and left mouse button held down, you can move the view freely while the selection is preserved. With very fine structures such as grids or stairs, it is worth zooming in extremely close so that you can control every pixel. If you do not use a graphics tablet, this step is especially important when working with a mouse.

Cutting out images in Photoshop: Combining tools strategically

Step 5: Using the Magic Wand with Tolerance and Contiguous

For areas of uniform color, the Magic Wand is often the right tool. Click into the area, and Photoshop selects similar color tones. The "Contiguous" option decides whether only connected pixels near your click are captured. If you deactivate it, all pixels with the corresponding color tone in the entire image are marked. With the tolerance, you control how much the color tones may differ. With the fine grid bars, the Magic Wand helps you capture the color of the structure, and you can add areas in several passes. Make sure the tolerance is not too high, otherwise areas of the subject that do not belong there will end up in the selection.

Cutting out images in Photoshop: Combining tools strategically

Step 6: Refine the Edge

Once the selection is roughly done, the most important quality step follows: "Refine Edge". Here you can check the selection against the background. For the check, set a solid background color such as black or white so that color fringes stand out immediately. With the Refine brush, you can rework untidy spots along the edge. At the transitions between the tower and the sky, the blue remnants disappear this way, and the fine bars of the lattice can also be worked out more cleanly. Use the radius and the contrast slider to create soft transitions. The color fringe is a typical sign that background pixels are still clinging to the edge.

Clipping paths in Photoshop: combining tools strategically

Step 7: Working with a Layer Mask

After refining the edge, you confirm the selection and convert it into a layer mask. This has a big advantage: the background is not deleted, only hidden. So you can make improvements at any time. With a black brush at full opacity, you paint away disruptive areas on the mask. Black hides, white reveals. Don't forget to click on the mask beforehand so that the brush takes effect there and not on the image itself.

Cutting out images in Photoshop: Combining tools strategically

Step 8: Insert and Transform a New Subject

With the cut-out object, you can now get creative. Drag a second image into your document, place it on a layer beneath the TV tower, and move it until the composition works. With the Transform controls, you rotate and scale the object. Hold down the Shift key to maintain the proportions. A missing shadow or a color fringe is immediately noticeable in the new environment. That's why you should always look at the result critically and keep editing the mask if needed.

Cutting out images in Photoshop: Combining tools strategically

Step 9: Remove the Color Fringe with an Adjustment Layer

If the color fringe is still visible after insertion, a Hue/Saturation adjustment layer helps. Create it above the object, reduce the saturation, and combine it as a clipping mask by holding down the Alt key. This way the correction only affects the layer beneath. Invert the mask with Ctrl + I and then paint with a white brush at low opacity exactly where the color fringe is disruptive. The advantage: the adjustment layer can be switched on and off at any time, so you can compare the difference directly.

Cutting out images in Photoshop: Combining tools strategically

Step 10: Cut Out the Football as a Separate Object

For round subjects like the football, the Elliptical Marquee selection is a good choice. To do this, zoom in closely on the subject and drag the selection around the ball. By holding down the space bar, you can move the selection if needed before you release the mouse button. It can also be adjusted afterwards via the context menu with "Transform Selection". With Ctrl + X you cut out the object, and with Ctrl + V you paste it back in as a new layer. This is especially handy if you then want to move or scale the ball or add effects to it.

Masking in Photoshop: Combining Tools Strategically

Step 11: Retouch Disruptive Spots

The empty spot that the ball leaves behind must be filled cleanly. The Clone Stamp used to be the tool of choice. You hold down the Alt key to set the source and then paint over the spot that is to be replaced. Today the Spot Healing Brush is often the faster way. Activate the "Content-Aware" option and simply paint over the disruptive area, while Photoshop automatically takes suitable pixels from the surroundings. Make sure you are working on the correct layer, usually the background layer. If the brush doesn't work as expected on a new, empty layer, it is often precisely this choice that is the cause.

Cutting out images in Photoshop: Combining tools strategically

Step 12: Create Motion Effects with Smart Objects

The football can be developed into a dynamic effect. Convert the layer into a Smart Object via the context menu. This allows you to shrink and enlarge the object without losing quality, as long as you don't go beyond the original size. Then, under "Filter", you apply a Motion Blur. Duplicate the layer with Ctrl + J, hide the filter, move the copy, and reduce its opacity. This creates the impression of a fast flight path. The layer order decides which parts are in the foreground.

Cutting out images in Photoshop: Combining tools strategically

Step 13: Using the Color Range for Complex Subjects

For subjects with a uniform color, such as a blue sky, the "Color Range" menu item offers a quick alternative. You select a color, and Photoshop marks all pixels with a similar hue. The tolerance determines how many tones are included. A value of around 120 may be sufficient for clear color gradients, but values that are too high cause parts of the subject to be captured as well. With the selection, you can then invert the sky and cleanly cut out the flowers with a layer mask. Here too: afterwards, check the edge using "Refine Edge".

Cutting out objects in Photoshop: combining tools strategically

Step 14: Creating a Realistic Drop Shadow

A cut-out object only looks believable when it casts a shadow. A drop shadow can be added via the layer's context menu. However, the default shadow often looks artificial. To adjust it, you drag the effect onto a new layer, shrink it, blur it more, and reduce the opacity. Think beforehand about where the light is coming from, and align the shadow accordingly. If necessary, you hide individual areas with a layer mask and a soft brush so that the shadow does not look equally dark everywhere.

Masking in Photoshop: Combining Tools Strategically

Step 15: Creating Copies with Smart Objects

For recurring elements such as hats, you save a lot of time with Smart Objects. Convert the cut-out hat into a Smart Object and duplicate it while holding down the Alt key. Each copy refers to the same original. If you change the original, for example via an adjustment layer for hue and saturation, all copies automatically adopt the change. To shrink, flip, or move them, you can edit the individual copies independently of one another. With Ctrl + T you flip horizontally so that the hats do not look identical.

Cutting out images in Photoshop: Combining tools strategically

Step 16: Bending Shapes with Puppet Warp

Finally, you can deform objects creatively. Puppet Warp sets anchor points with which you can bend areas. Place the pins at points where the object should bend, and drag them in the desired direction. With the Alt key held down, points can also be moved. This creates, for example, a kink in the TV tower. The tool is ideal for humorous montages or for small corrections to shapes that are easy to distort.

Masking in Photoshop: Combining Tools Strategically

Summary ??? Cutting Out in Photoshop: Combining Tools Purposefully

Cutting out becomes much more pleasant when you do not view the tools as individual solutions, but as a team. The Quick Selection tool provides quick initial access, the Shift and Alt keys refine the selection, the Magic Wand handles uniform areas of color, and "Refine Edge" ensures clean transitions. Layer masks, adjustment layers, and Smart Objects keep your result flexible so that you can readjust at any time. If you internalize this sequence, you will work more routinely with every image.

FAQ

Which selection tool should I use to get started?The Quick Selection tool is suitable for most subjects with clear contrast and is the fastest starting point.

Why are my edges messy after cutting out?Often it is due to remnants of the old background. Use "Refine Edge" and check the edge against a solid-color background.

How do I remove an area from my selection?Hold down the Alt key and drag a selection tool over the area you want to subtract.

How do I add more areas to a selection?Hold down the Shift key while working with a selection tool.

What does a layer mask offer compared to deleting the background?With a layer mask, the background is preserved and can be shown again or corrected at any time.

When do I use the Magic Wand?The Magic Wand is ideal for areas of uniform color. With "Contiguous" and the tolerance, you control which pixels are captured.

Why should I use Smart Objects?Smart Objects allow resizing without loss of quality and automatically apply changes to all copies.

How do I get a realistic drop shadow?Put the shadow on its own layer, adjust size, blur, and opacity, and align it according to the light source.

815,590,667,689,274,622
Stefan Petri
Trainer About Stefan Petri Together with his brother Matthias, Stefan Petri runs the popular specialist forum PSD-Tutorials.de and the e-learning platform TutKit.com, which focuses on the training and further education of digital professional skills. All courses by Stefan Petri